How to Choose the Right Eye Primer for Your Unique Skin Type

When it comes to choosing the right eye primer, there are a few things to keep in mind. These include your skin type, how often you wear makeup, and what you're looking for from the product.

Oily vs Dry Lids

If you have oily lids, you'll want to choose an eyeshadow primer that will help your makeup last as long as possible without fading or creasing. This might mean opting for a waterproof or smudge-proof formula, like the SMASHBOX 24-hour Photo Finish Eye Primer or Benefit Stay Don't Stray Eyeshadow Primer.

Alternatively, you can opt for a hydrating primer that will provide a smooth base for your makeup to adhere to. This may mean opting for a cream primer, such as the MILK MAKEUP Hydro Grip Eyeshadow and Concealer Primer, or one that has a matte texture, like the e.l.f. Cosmetics Matte Putty Primer, to accommodate your skin's needs.

Pigmented vs Translucent Primers

There are also several different types of eyeshadow primers available on the market, so it's important to know your goals before settling on one. Some are completely transparent while others are tinted or even pigmented, meaning they can act as a base for shadows or boost the vibrancy of them.

The former is ideal if you're trying to conceal discoloration, while the latter can be useful if you're aiming to make your shadows appear more vibrant on your eyes. The best way to find out what's right for your specific skin tone is to patch test the product on a small area of your face before using it every day.

Sensitive vs Non-Sensitive Lids

If you're looking for an eyeshadow primer to soothe your sensitive eyelids, this product by URBAN DECAY might be just what you need. It's formulated with anti-inflammatory botanicals, including aloe, arnica, and rosehip, and it works to brighten the area while soothing any redness or irritation.

To use it, apply a thin layer on the eyelid with your fingertip or a brush. The formula can be thicker than the rest of your makeup, so it's essential to tap it gently into the skin. You can also try applying it with a mascara brush, but be sure to avoid dragging the product into your lashes as this will cause them to fall out.

Some people prefer to apply foundation on their eyelids instead of eyeshadow primer, but this isn't recommended as it can result in eyeshadow creasing and a lack of long-lasting wear. In addition, the heavier, more viscous formula of foundation can create a barrier between your eyeshadow and your skin, which can make it appear a little cakey and less than smooth.

How to Choose the Right Eye Primer for Your Unique Skin Type

A good eye primer is essential to make your makeup last longer, look more vibrant and prevent smudging or creasing. But it can be tricky to choose the right one for your unique skin type.

Dry skin needs a primer that's lightweight and hydrating. If you have oily skin, find one that controls oil without being too matte.

Oily Skin

An eye primer might seem like a luxury that gets pushed to the back of your beauty routine, but it can make all the difference in keeping eyeshadow smudge-proof for long hours. It can prevent smudging, fading, and run-off that can happen when your skin is oily or sweaty.

If you’re dealing with greasy lids, look for an eyeshadow primer that’s specially formulated for the unique needs of your eyes. It should be lightweight, smudge-proof, and hydrate for extended wear.

NYX’s Ultimate Shadow & Liner Primer is a colour-boosting formula that keeps eyeshadow pigment bright and vibrant, even on oily skin. It also covers visible veins and discolouration to make your eyeshadow last longer.

One GH product expert loved this drugstore primer, saying it felt light and hydrating on her sensitive eyelids. She also appreciated the color-boosting primer’s smooth application and crease-proof formula.

Dry Skin

If you have dry skin, then you need to choose an eye primer that hydrates your skin and has a smooth finish. This will help your eyeshadow last longer without fading or creasing.

It also helps your makeup blend easily, reducing the chances of getting creases or smudges. You can also apply it before your eyeshadow, so that it dries before the shadows go on.

A good eye primer can be your secret weapon for making eyeshadow look more vibrant and long-wearing, says Williams. She recommends using a base that is skin-like or a few shades lighter than your natural shade to give the eyeshadow color extra pop.

For mature skin, you can use a tinted primer to even out your skin tone and conceal discolorations. But it’s important to keep in mind that tinted primers can sometimes make your eyeshadow look more muddy, so stick to transparent options or ones that are very light.

Normal Skin

Skin physiology is constantly changing and varies according to the weather, hormones, stress and lifestyle habits like diet and exercise. It is also influenced by toxins and stressors from the environment.

This is why it’s essential to keep your skin in balance with a gentle daily skincare routine that includes cleanser, moisturizer and SPF. You can also add a serum to brighten, hydrate and smooth your complexion.

The most foolproof eye primers are ones that start out beige or off-white and get colorless as they spread out. That’s what makes them so versatile, especially when paired with eyeshadow and liner.

While it may be tempting to skip the cleansing, moisturizing and SPF routine because you have normal skin, that’s not a valid option for achieving and maintaining optimal results. As Dr Machiwala explains, it’s important to take the time to create a regular, dedicated skincare regimen so that your skin stays healthy.

Combination Skin

If you’ve ever tried to create a skincare routine that targets both oily skin and dry skin, you know that it can be challenging. That’s because both types of skin need different ingredients, which is why it’s important to choose the right products for your unique skin type.

For example, if you have combination skin, you’ll need a hydrating cleanser to keep your face healthy and balanced. But you’ll also need a mattifying formula that doesn’t over-dry your cheeks and under-eye area.

Celebrity esthetician Lisa Guidi recommends that you look for a product with a lightweight texture. These are often formulated with hyaluronic acid, which helps hydrate the skin without making it feel greasy. Plus, they’re infused with antioxidants like pomegranate extract and vitamin C.